originally published at gitblog but some of my thinking about a new mozart (cf. appendix) and our brave new forthcoming blockbusters fired up the relevant neurons of my mind to republish.

i. opportunity dances with those already on the dance floor

from the depths of twittersphere, a johann cruyff --

Speed is often confused with insight.
When I start running
earlier than the others, I appear faster.

cruyff was alas not the speediest in this insight; others sportsmen (gretzky skates to where the puck is going to be; precision beats power, and timing beats speed for mcgregor; palmer gets luckier the more he practices) and non-sportsmen (chance favors the prepared mind; never confuse motion for action; slow is smooth, smooth is fast) found their way there.

h jackson brown just found the most poetic one, and krakauer bridges it to some flowery philosophy. opportunity dances with those already on the dance floor

ii. the interview

intelligence is the thing we do that ensures the problem is efficiently solved in a way that makes it appear effortless. stupidity is assertive rules that we use to ensure that the problem will be solved in longer than chance or never right and and is nevertheless pursued. tl;dr

  • stupid makes easy problems hard.

  • intelligent makes hard problems easy.

  • genius makes problems go away

with reference to great interview.

the rubik's cube [is a beautiful mental model]. If I gave you a cube and I asked you to solve it and you just randomly manipulated it since it has on the order of 10 quintillion solutions—a very large number—you basically, if you were immortal would eventually solve it but it would take the lifetime of several universes to do so.

[...] that is random performance.

yet a proper model of the domain allows you to induce parsimonious, mindlessly applicable processes. we develop rules.

[rules] allow you from any initial configuration to so the cube in 20 moves or less that is intelligent behavior so significantly better than chance. and this sounds a little counterintuitive perhaps until you realize that's how we use the word in our daily lives.
if I sat down with an extraordinary mathematician and I said I can't solve that equation and they say well no it's easy here this what you do and you look at you say oh yes it is easy right you made that look easy that's what we mean when we say someone is smart

the concept of IQ is useless. @36m40s "I would dispute the g concept of intelligence."

young Mozart acquired perfect pitch, could recollect scores note-for-note, etc. because his father was a tyrant who drilled into Mozart and his sister all of this. in a loving family, would mozart have acquired this? deliberate practice affords extraordinary skills. g measures working memory and that strongly correlates with many tasks.

from the interview, two things jump out:

  1. 1.

    krakauer does not mention Polgar sisters

  2. 2.

    Mozart's sister did not become equally extraordinary as Mozart.

Re (2): the defence says there are innate variations @39m31s. which does at least a portion of heavy lifting. perhaps this variance in preferences or natural ability should suppress the variance in environment (Mozart's tyrannical father).

on representation @43m22s. roman numerals make it inefficient to perform math. in India / Arabia, they would at the same time be able to effortlessly perform the same calculations.

This is a good example of cultural transmission. and a "Complementary Cognitive Artefact." @47m2s such as

  • The Abacus. expert users modify their brain s.t. they have "an abacus" in the cortex. it shifts from language to visuo-spatial areas. this exemplifies an object in the world intelligently restructuring the brain.

  • Maps. sextant, quadrant, etc. familiarity reduces reliance.

in contrast to competitive @49m38s artefacts

  • Calculator. Me and my phone are very smart. But if we take (the phone) away, I didn't get any benefit. The artefact does not amplify but rather replace my ability.

    • This is not a normative recommendation.

  • Of course, Machine Learning.

    • AlphaGo is mentioned however I am not convinced that this is 100% true; famously human strategy seems often positively modulated by the use of computer tools.

      • So is it possible that in some contexts the artefact is competitive, while in others complementary? Is it not similar with maps mentioned above?!

  • A car. Clearly allows us to move more efficiently along a surface. But take it away, and you are not any better than before (in fact, worse).

  • (he does not mention this but came to my mind) Glasses.

We accept the tradeoffs because the utility value of these artefacts is so high. glasses, calculators, cars; modern world would not work without them.

the real discussion that we should be having is that might be a discussion in a hundred years time but the imminent and practical debate is what to do about competitive cognitive artifacts that are already leaving an impression on our brains that is arguably negative.

Sam claims David is making normative claims even though he says he's not. @58m20s Normative claims in his mind enter via "we (as humans) want to be better."

David: "I agree there are in some domains better ways of being, e.g. imagine we would still be writing code on punched cards or binary." @59m10s

But I suppose in his framework, computer languages would be ambiguous. not complementary in the sense that they replace our ability to code in binary; yet provide an efficient abstraction for thinking about code that binary could never offer.

iii. the callback

and how did mozart become famous as a 6 yo? relentless eu touring (child prodigy), royal patronage (blockbuster operas, public concerts, newspapers, gossip), and the booming sheet music industry.

to krakauer's hypothetical. in a loving family, would mozart have acquired his ability?

seems jacob got famous at adulthood via quincy jones' youtube-sourced patronage. if jacob's 12-year price for eschewing a tyrannical father was the road not taken... doesn't seem half bad. by krakauer's own definition, it's just less intelligent.

by musical critics' definition, we should further resent the fact collier to merely possess technical ability to complexify existing harmonies. oh well. i resent the lack of musical creativity expositions such as the one below. thanks to andrew for the h/t.